Compare
Redlamp and Lightroom, feature by feature
The Lightroom features photographers know, and where Redlamp stands on each. Redlamp is in alpha, so much of the list is still ahead; each row says plainly what works, what's being built and what isn't coming. Features that work haven't yet been compared with Lightroom's results unless a row says so.
- Done
- 114
- In progress
- 25
- Planned
- 30
- Later
- 12
- Undecided
- 10
- Out of scope
- 6
- Done:
- works in the app today.
- In progress:
- being built.
- Planned:
- on the roadmap, in the phase shown.
- Later:
- after 1.0.
- Undecided:
- Lightroom has it; Redlamp hasn't decided yet.
- Out of scope:
- left out, with the reason.
- Not yet compared:
- works, but its results haven't been checked against Lightroom's side by side.
- Behind, Beyond or Different:
- a known gap, more than Lightroom does, or a different approach by design.
Lightroom checked against: Lightroom Classic 15.6 and the Lightroom Desktop and mobile releases of September 2026, from The Lightroom Queen's release notes (checked 12 October 2026); not yet against Adobe's own pages. Read from docs/lightroom-comparison.md at commit 9117a46, which follows the project's tracker; each row links to its GitHub issue, where the work can be followed and discussed.
197 features
Files and cameras
6 of 11 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Raw files from most cameras Through LibRaw 0.22, built from Redlamp's fork; 35 cameras are verified by the decode tests, Hasselblad and Phase One medium format among them (every camera). Nikon's High Efficiency NEFs open from the six bodies that write them, and raws other than DNG use one colour matrix per camera, where DNGs blend two by white balance | Yes | DoneBehind Lightroom | #14#18#168#169#367 |
Each camera's default brightness A raw opens about as bright as its camera's own JPEG, from a table of 576 cameras Redlamp measures from the camera bench's CC0 files, with a calibration from a target in its place; held out, every maker's median lands within a tenth of a stop. From process 19, a Fujifilm raw shot at DR200 or DR400 opens as bright as at DR100 (CAM-35); photos whose other camera settings brighten their JPEG, such as Canon's Highlight Tone Priority, still open darker. Not yet compared with Lightroom's defaults (ARC-16) | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #359#366#442 |
Fujifilm X-Trans raw files Markesteijn's demosaic, which resolves a sharp edge as finely as Redlamp's Bayer demosaic (DN-11). Fujifilm exposure differs from the camera's by up to ±0.9 EV, depending on the body | Yes | DoneBehind Lightroom | #20 |
Apple ProRAW and other phone DNGs Gain maps and embedded camera profiles are applied, and ProRAW can render with the iPhone's own look | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #16#17#29 |
JPEG XL DNGs Linear ones (iPhone ProRAW) open; JPEG XL mosaic DNGs don't yet | Yes | In progress· Phase 2 | #23 |
Testing your own camera The camera bench checks your raws against the camera's own JPEG on your Mac, and sends only the measurements, which add to the cameras page | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #174#175#176#177 |
JPEG, HEIC, TIFF and PNG Shown as the file at default settings, as Lightroom does | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #42 |
PSD, AVIF and JPEG XL files | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #378 |
WebP files Undecided Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Undecided | |
Per-camera raw defaults By camera, lens, ISO and file type | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #68 |
Tethered capture Researched in October 2026: capture sessions and a hot folder for any camera first, then camera control and Live View for Canon, Nikon, Sony and Fujifilm, and wireless (findings) | YesClassic | Later | #194#195#197#199#200#201#202#204#206#207 |
Video Redlamp develops still photos Out of scope Lightroom: Yesbasic trims | Yesbasic trims | Out of scope |
Light and colour
17 of 25 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
White balance: presets, Temp and Tint, eyedropper and Auto A camera white-balance model built on each camera's colour matrix DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Exposure, Contrast, Highlights, Shadows, Whites and Blacks Highlights and Shadows keep the texture inside each region for new edits | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #9#25 |
Auto settings A heuristic Auto, as a starting point DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Texture, Clarity and Dehaze Clarity and Dehaze follow the photo's edges for new edits, so a skyline gets no bright and dark bands, and negative Dehaze adds haze where the photo is hazy, as Lightroom's does | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #26#157#482 |
Vibrance and Saturation Boosts stop at the edge of the output's colours instead of clipping | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #27 |
Tone curve: parametric and point curves With split points and the point curve's presets DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Tone curve: separate red, green and blue curves Chosen from a Channel menu under the point curve; Lightroom presets' channel curves come across | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #379 |
Targeted Adjustment Tool Drag on the photo to move a curve or a colour band | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #322 |
Color Mixer: hue, saturation and luminance per colour Works in OKLCh DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Black and white DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
B&W mix: brightness per colour band Today the Color Mixer's Luminance shapes a black-and-white photo | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #380 |
Point Color Lightroom's now has a Variance slider too, which evens out similar colours; Redlamp's adds Capture One's separate hue, saturation and lightness uniformity, for skin | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #181 |
Color Grading Shadows, midtones, highlights and global wheels, with Blending and Balance DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Profiles Profiles are Base Looks, chosen in Basic or from a Base Looks panel of their own before Recipes, with its own search: six built-in looks, 15 film styles, the film stocks and imported LUTs, each with an Amount slider (0–200) | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #66 |
Camera-matching looks Four looks measured from Fujifilm cameras' own JPEGs (one provisional), under Redlamp's own names | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #34 |
More camera-matching looks (Eterna, Classic Negative, Acros and others) Need more photos with the camera's JPEG beside the raw; Fujifilm's own LUTs for ten simulations, downloaded from Fujifilm, import in one step and fill the film slots; a model of the camera's own processing for twenty simulations, with their tone and colour settings, is an experiment turned on in Settings | Yes | In progress· Phase 3 | #34#40#327#388#389#390#428#429 |
DNG camera profiles Dual-illuminant colour and the embedded HueSatMap; a profile's look is offered as a Base Look | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #17#29 |
Custom `.dcp` camera profiles Your own | Yes | In progress· Phase 2 | #432 |
Adobe's profiles: Adobe Color, Portrait, Landscape and the others Your own copies, where Lightroom Classic or Camera Raw installs them, as Base Looks with their Amount, used on your Mac only; edits brought from Lightroom render in the Adobe profile they name when it's on your Mac | Yes | In progress· Phase 2 | #433#434 |
ICC input profiles | No | Planned· Phase 2 | #30 |
A scene-referred rendering for reproduction work, with exposure tied to the camera's metering The Base Look Redlamp Reproduction: no tone curve or look, and each camera's exposure calibrated from a target, so a metered grey scale exports at its own L*; Lightroom needs a custom linear profile for this | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #360#359 |
Calibration panel Shadows Tint and the red, green and blue primaries DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Process versions An edit keeps rendering the way it was made; moving it to a newer process is your choice | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #2 |
HDR editing and export | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #381 |
Adaptive (AI) profile and personalised auto settings | Yes | Later | #134#135 |
Detail
2 of 5 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Sharpening Lightroom's four controls; the photo's noise and grain aren't sharpened | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #127 |
Noise reduction Lightroom's six controls, scaled to each photo's measured noise. From process 16, values below black are kept until after noise reduction, so the deepest shadows at high ISO keep their colour; strong Luminance still reads the noisiest of them a little dark (DN-16). Calibrated profiles for the first ten bodies wait on calibration shots | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #102#103#293 |
AI Denoise On the Mac, working on the raw data, as an edit rather than a new file, as Lightroom has done since June 2025. Open-source raw denoisers are measured first (DN-17); Redlamp's own network, one that demosaics and denoises Bayer and X-Trans, is the alternative (DN-11) | Yes | In progress· Phase 3 | #107#108#109#518 |
Super Resolution 2x and 4x, faithful to the photo rather than inventing detail | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #124#125 |
Raw Details Proposed as the noise-free mode of the AI Denoise network; a learned demosaic measured 4.5 dB better than Redlamp's on Bayer photos, mostly in fine colour detail (DN-11) | Yes | Later | DEC-36 |
Lens and geometry
9 of 12 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Lens corrections the raw file carries DNG opcodes, Sony's and Fujifilm's built-in corrections, and from process 16 Panasonic's and OM System's distortion, framed as in the camera's own JPEG | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #79#80 |
Chromatic aberration and vignetting from Panasonic and OM System raws Their distortion corrections apply from process 16; the fringing and vignetting data the files carry don't match the cameras' JPEGs yet, and Remove Chromatic Aberration still works on them | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #443 |
Adobe LCP lens profiles Profiles you put in Redlamp's Lens Profiles folder and, from process 17, those Lightroom Classic and Camera Raw install, read where they are, and profiles made on another body whose sensor covers the photo's; Lightroom's Setup, Make, Model and Profile menus choose one by hand; Redlamp doesn't ship Adobe's | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #82#159#436#437#438 |
Fisheye lens profiles From process 17, a fisheye profile turns the photo rectilinear by the Adobe Camera Model's fisheye equations; the fisheye warp in a DNG Converter's DNG isn't read yet | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #439 |
A built-in lens profile database The lensfun database, once a licence question is answered | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #81 |
Manual distortion and vignetting DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Remove Chromatic Aberration and Defringe From the lens profile, or measured from the photo's own edges | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #87 |
Upright: Auto, Level, Vertical, Full and Guided Corrects only where the photo's straight edges agree | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #85#86 |
Transform sliders | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #83 |
Crop and straighten Aspect presets, Lightroom's overlays, the Straighten tool and Constrain to Image | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #84 |
Custom crop ratios, and rotating by dragging outside the crop Enter Custom… takes a ratio or a size in pixels and keeps the five most recent; a button beside the Aspect menu swaps portrait and landscape; a drag outside the crop turns the photo, with a fine grid | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #352#353 |
Lens Blur | Yes | Later | #416#417#418#419#420#421#422 |
Effects
5 of 5 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Post-crop vignette With Highlights, to keep bright areas bright DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Grain Sized to the frame and strongest in the shadows, as film's is | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #39 |
Halation and bloom The glow film gives bright lights | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #37#38 |
Light leaks, dust and scratches | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #45 |
Borders and frames Around the photo, the canvas growing to Instagram, Stories or paper shapes, with film and instant frames, shown while editing and kept with the edit, a Borders folder in Recipes and a Border menu at export; Lightroom Classic makes borders only in its Print module (Print to JPEG included) or through export plug-ins | PartlyClassic, when printing | DoneBeyond Lightroom | #471#472#473 |
Masking
24 of 24 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Linear and radial gradients DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Brush, with Auto Mask and pen pressure | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #61 |
Color and luminance range | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #51 |
Subject, Sky and Background Computed on the Mac; photos are never uploaded. Sky also uses Depth Anything 3, an open model trained partly on data Redlamp couldn't use itself. Edges are solved when a mask is made, not refined again as you edit | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #53#62 |
People and their parts A picker shows who is in the photo as crops to tick, with the parts to mask and a mask for each person if you like. Face parts from Apple Vision; body skin, clothes and hair from SAM 3, a download under Meta's SAM License | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #53#58#302 |
Objects Hover to preview, click to select (Segment Anything 2.1, an 80 MB download, an open model trained partly on data Redlamp couldn't use itself) | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #55 |
Objects by rectangle and brush | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #252 |
Landscape A picker lists the regions found, each with its share of the photo, to mask together or one each: water, vegetation, mountains, architecture, ground and snow, from SAM 3 (a 988 MB download under Meta's SAM License) | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #62#255#307 |
Snow in Landscape masks, and adaptive Landscape presets | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #255 |
Depth Range From the photo's own depth map, or estimated by Depth Anything, an open model trained partly on data Redlamp couldn't use itself | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #59 |
Refine AI mask edges Refine Edges, which solves a mask's whole edge again per pixel, and a Refine Edge brush that solves an edge again where you paint; from process 13, coarse masks (iPhone mattes, face parts) refined at full resolution as the photo is drawn | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #1#270#275 |
Feather and Edge sliders for AI masks Lightroom Classic 15.5 added the sliders | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #251 |
Mask presets (Blue Sky, Whiten Teeth and others) On one photo or every selected photo at once, each one's AI masks made for it; save your own from any mask | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #306 |
Effect presets for a mask's adjustments (Dodge, Burn, Soften Skin and others) Nine of Redlamp's own, with values of its own, which set a mask's sliders and Curves; the skin and teeth effects are named Smooth Skin and Whiten Teeth, as the mask presets are. Save your own from any mask | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #308 |
Add, Subtract, Intersect, invert and duplicate A component or the whole mask inverted; Duplicate and Invert inverts the copy as a whole | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #305 |
A masks panel with a thumbnail of each mask, and its overlay on hover One picker for every mask and component, a menu on each mask and component, pins where each mask covers most, and Option-click on an eye to show one mask alone | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #301#303#304#305 |
Reorder masks and components, every overlay mode and its opacity | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #254 |
Local adjustments in masks Local Whites and Blacks move the end points as the global sliders do, for new edits (process 13) | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #49#257 |
Local Whites and Blacks as true end points | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #257 |
Color swatch inside masks | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #256 |
Curves inside masks | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #253 |
Point Color inside masks With an Even Skin Tone preset on Face Skin and Body Skin | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #181 |
Update AI masks across photos Pasted and synced settings recompute their AI masks for each photo | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #149 |
Reuse a mask inside another, and keep only its textured areas Lightroom can start a new mask from an existing one; Redlamp also adds, subtracts or intersects one inside another, and a mask's Detail keeps only its textured or flat areas | Partly | DoneBeyond Lightroom | #50#52 |
Healing and removal
7 of 10 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Heal and Clone Spots and brushed strokes, each finding its own source | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #118 |
Content-aware Remove A classical fill on the Mac; large areas are for Generative Remove | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #153 |
Remove people and objects with a click Their cast shadows and their reflections on water go with them | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #154#173 |
Pick an object to remove with a rough stroke (Detect Objects) Or with a box dragged around it, with Click picks on Object; a stroke over a part a pick left out adds it to that pick | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #365 |
Find and remove things named in words Trash, signs, cables and more, found anywhere in the photo; something as large as a car needs Generative Remove, since content-aware fill leaves a smeared patch | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #154 |
Generative Remove on large areas and hard scenes Fills as sharp as the photo on large areas, which are filled at a coarser resolution today, and clean on water and buildings, where content-aware fill's streaks can carry into them | Yescloud, credits | In progress· Phase 3 | #519#520 |
Generative Remove Runs on the Mac, without a cloud or credits, from an opt-in 2.4 GB download; tested on Macs with 16 GB or more, and offered on smaller ones with a note that it hasn't been tested there; fills are labelled as generated | Yescloud, credits | DoneDifferent approach | #156#297 |
Dust removal and Visualize Spots Also across a shoot: specks in the same place on the sensor are healed in every photo | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #119 |
Reflection removal For photos taken through glass, on the Mac; open models are surveyed first | Yes | In progress· Phase 3 | #521 |
Red Eye and Pet Eye | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #136 |
Generative and cloud AI
0 of 5 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Generative Expand: fill beyond the frame Undecided Lightroom: YesDesktop and mobile, not Classic | YesDesktop and mobile, not Classic | Undecided | |
Generative Upscale (Topaz) Redlamp's planned Super Resolution is faithful rather than generative | YesDesktop; cloud, credits | Undecided | DEC-14 |
AI sharpening for blur and missed focus (Topaz) Proposed for Redlamp as a head on its own raw denoiser, on the Mac | YesDesktop; cloud, credits | Undecided | #129 |
Edit by describing the result (Prompt to Edit, Firefly) Undecided Lightroom: YesDesktop early access; cloud, credits | YesDesktop early access; cloud, credits | Undecided | |
Generative and AI tools run in the cloud An option for later, beside the models that run on the Mac: a provider you bring your own key for, a third-party provider, or a ComfyUI server (DEC-39) | Yescloud, credits | Later | #309#331#299 |
Presets and looks
8 of 9 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Presets Presets are Recipes, with an Amount slider (0–200); a recipe can set a Base Look, as a preset can include a profile, and its row shows it; Lightroom's words still work in search | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #69 |
Lightroom presets (`.xmp`) Imported with a report of what came across exactly, approximately or not at all. Sliders aren't yet calibrated against Lightroom's renders, so a preset can look different | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #73#313 |
LUTs (`.cube`, `.3dl`, HaldCLUT) Imported directly into Base Looks, including LUTs made for camera log footage; Lightroom takes LUTs only wrapped as profiles | Partly | DoneBeyond Lightroom | #31#158 |
Film stock simulations (Portra, Tri-X and others) 36 looks from 30 stocks, built from the manufacturers' datasheets; Lightroom's film-inspired presets don't replicate particular films | Partlyfilm-inspired presets | DoneBeyond Lightroom | #41#46 |
Film looks fitted from film shot beside digital With charts and lab scans, per stock | No | Planned· Phase 3 | #43 |
Camera recipe cards Fujifilm-style recipes, typed in as the card lists them DoneOnly in Redlamp Lightroom: No | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | |
Each look in one place, with its icon Each look listed once in the Base Looks panel, film stocks with their icons; Basic's Base Look menu keeps Redlamp's own looks and shows a film stock or LUT only while it's the photo's look | Noprofiles in Basic, presets in the left panel | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #404 |
Profiles apart from presets A Base Looks panel before Recipes lists every look, film stock and LUT in folders, with its own search and favourites; Recipes keeps the presets, and a recipe that sets a look shows it; a film stock brings its own grain, halation and bloom and leaves the rest of the edit DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yesprofiles in Basic's Profile Browser, presets in the left panel#469 | Yesprofiles in Basic's Profile Browser, presets in the left panel | DoneNot yet compared | #469 |
Show presets in Finder, delete them, hide preset groups Show in Finder and Move to Trash for your own and installed recipes and imported looks, without changing the photos edited with them, and Remove from Base Looks for an installed look no recipe uses; built-in folders hidden from either panel, its search and ⌘K, and shown again from the panel header's right-click menu | YesManage Presets hides groups | DoneNot yet compared | #470 |
Premium and recommended presets Redlamp has no cloud service Out of scope Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | Out of scope |
Working on many photos
5 of 9 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Folders A working set of folders, not a catalog; nothing on disk is moved | YesClassic | DoneDifferent approach | #99 |
Copy and paste settings Lightroom's checklist, remembered; also from a filmstrip photo's context menu | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #70#191 |
Sync and Auto Sync Undo with Auto Sync on gives each photo its own edit back, as in Lightroom | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #149#150#192 |
Ratings, flags and colour labels Saved with the photo's edit, shown in the grid, the loupe and the filmstrip DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Batch export | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #78 |
Batch rename Rename Photos (F2): naming templates shared with importing, batch export and capture sessions, a live preview of every new name, and Undo; Move to Folder and Copy to Folder from the menus, photos dragged onto a folder (⌥ to copy), and Stop partway | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #239#240 |
Open photos edited in Lightroom Converts the edits in Lightroom's XMP sidecars, and in the XMP inside DNG, JPEG, TIFF and HEIC files, once: when you open the photo, or for a folder or selection with Convert Lightroom Edits…, with a report and Undo; raws use your own Adobe profiles where they're on your Mac; never writes Lightroom's XMP | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #74 |
Bring a Lightroom Classic catalog's edits across Each photo's develop settings and snapshots, converted once with a report before anything is written, and taken back by Undo Import, read without changing the catalog; each virtual copy comes across as a version of its photo, and a photo already edited in Redlamp gets Lightroom's edit as a version; masks and spots, turns made in Lightroom and Process 2003 and 2010 tone not yet; its ratings, keywords and collections come across with the library; one window finds the catalog, the presets in Camera Raw's Settings folder and your Adobe profiles, and edits render in those profiles when they're on your Mac | YesLightroom's migration from Classic | In progress· Phase 4 | #312#434#435 |
Match Total Exposures | YesClassic | Undecided | #310 |
History and versions
4 of 6 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
History and unlimited undo The last 20 editing sessions are kept with the photo DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Snapshots DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Virtual copies and versions Versions of a photo in its one sidecar, each with its own edit, history, snapshots and metadata: Develop makes, opens, renames and removes them, and a catalog's virtual copies come across as versions (EDT-23); each is a photo of its own in the library, as Lightroom Classic's virtual copies are, with its own rating, flag, label, keywords and collections, shown beside its photo in an open stack, found by Copy Status, compared, synced and exported as itself, renamed in the Metadata panel's Copy Name and removed alone | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #71#399 |
Before and after Three layouts DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Before and after: your choice of layout, Copy and Swap Left/right or top/bottom by choice, Copy Before's or After's settings, and Swap; Redlamp orients side by side from the photo's shape | Yes | Undecided | #318 |
Reference view | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #321 |
Viewing
13 of 18 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Zoom, Navigator and clipping Fit, Fill, 1:1 and 2:1; Lightroom zooms to 11:1 DoneBehind Lightroom Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneBehind Lightroom | |
Zoom, pan and brush sizes in every tool The wheel zooms and Space pans while masking, healing and cropping, and every brush sizes with [ and ] or ⌘-scroll | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #258 |
Panels that hide automatically or stay up The filmstrip hides automatically or stays up with the photo fitted above it (the pin on the filmstrip, View › Filmstrip, its right-click menu, Settings); Lightroom offers Auto Hide & Show, Auto Hide and Manual for each panel | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #292#396 |
Filmstrip scroll bar and thumbnail sizes Also Home and End for the first and last photo, and the line of text above the thumbnails made optional | YesClassic | DoneNot yet compared | #376 |
Histogram you can drag to adjust DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
RGB and L*a*b* values of the pixel under the pointer Under the histogram; RGB in Display P3, where Lightroom uses Melissa RGB, and L*a*b* relative to D50 | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #319 |
Readout points pinned on the photo As Photoshop's colour samplers, with values that stay while sliders move | No | Planned· Phase 3 | #363 |
Panel on/off switches Turn a panel's settings off and on without losing them | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #317 |
Hiding Develop panels you don't use From a panel header's right-click menu; a hidden panel that holds edits shows anyway | YesClassic | Planned· Phase 2 | #368 |
Reordering Develop panels Undecided Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Undecided | |
Typing a slider's value Arithmetic works too ( | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #92 |
A value on every control, and values that scrub when dragged Including the grading wheels, the curve's points, Base Look Amount and the Masks panel's sizes and ranges, each typed or scrubbed | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #315#316 |
Lightroom Classic's keyboard shortcuts 186 actions on 135 key bindings DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Your own keyboard shortcuts Any action on the key you choose, with keymaps for people coming from Lightroom Classic, Photo Mechanic and Bridge | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #261 |
Command palette Every action and slider from the keyboard (⌘K) | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #98 |
Sensor clipping and a colour-assessment view | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #96 |
Soft proofing | YesClassic | Planned· Phase 2 | #30 |
Secondary display The grid, loupe, Compare or Survey on another screen | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #234 |
Merging photos
1 of 5 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Focus stacking Stacks are found for you; merge, view the depth map and retouch, and the result develops like a raw | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #112#113#115 |
Focus stacking: lens corrections, halo handling and DNG output | No | In progress· Phase 3 | #113#114 |
AI-assisted focus stacking Fewer frames, handheld sequences, better edges | No | Planned· Phase 4 | #117 |
HDR merge | Yes | Later | #139 |
Panorama | Yes | Later | #139 |
Export
5 of 13 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
JPEG, HEIC, AVIF, PNG and TIFF 8, 10 or 16 bits, in sRGB or Display P3 | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #75#77 |
Size, metadata and export presets With Export with Previous | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #77 |
Adobe RGB, ProPhoto and custom ICC output | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #361 |
JPEG XL output Lossy or lossless | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #373 |
DNG and PSD output | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #382 |
Watermarks Your logo or text, such as each photo's capture date, placed, sized and faded, horizontal or vertical | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #314 |
Output sharpening | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #383 |
Edit in Photoshop or another app | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #384 |
Sharing to other apps Share… hands the exported photos to macOS's share sheet: Mail, Messages, AirDrop and the apps that add themselves to it | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #515 |
Content Credentials | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #120 |
The edit embedded in exported files | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #76 |
Command-line rendering and export The DoneOnly in Redlamp Lightroom: No | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | |
Plug-ins for export, publishing and metadata Lightroom Classic runs plug-ins written for its SDK; Redlamp's nearest are the Undecided Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Undecided |
Library and organising
6 of 26 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Catalog An index on your Mac of the folders you add, designed for a million photos and rebuilt from the photos and their sidecars at any time; a folder taken out of it leaves every view, and comes back whole from its sidecars when added again; edits and metadata kept beside the photos or on this Mac, moved between the two from a folder's menu; folders on your disk stay the organisation, and edits and metadata stay beside each photo or in Redlamp on this Mac; thumbnails and previews are kept so slow and disconnected drives can be browsed; a photo deleted or moved outside Redlamp stays as missing, with everything decided about it, listed only in Library Health until it's located or removed | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #219#221#222#223#224#225 |
Editing photos whose drive is disconnected (Smart Previews) Lightroom Classic develops them from a smaller copy of each raw it keeps; Redlamp's library keeps thumbnails and previews to browse disconnected drives Undecided Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Undecided | |
Library and Develop modules One window, switched by a key or a click, with the selection, source, filter, sort and filmstrip carried across, and one Undo for both | YesClassic | DoneNot yet compared | #227 |
Search and filters Results as you type; a filter bar of text, attributes and metadata columns with counts, sorts and saved filters, in one query language with the command palette, smart collections and the command line; traits such as long exposures and wide-open, telephoto and ultra-wide shots; an empty search names the filter in its way, or a name a typo away; text found whatever its accents and width, so sao finds São Paulo; names found with a typo or by their letters in order, in completion and the palette | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #220#226#232#233 |
Grid, Loupe, Compare and Survey Held arrow keys move through photos without waiting; thumbnails show the edit; Compare and Survey built | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #228#230#231 |
Judging photos while culling Sensor clipping and a raw histogram in the loupe and Compare, since a raw's embedded JPEG hides clipping, with focus peaking, the camera's focus point and a loupe that follows the pointer | No | In progress· Phase 4 | #263 |
Rating, flagging and labelling many photos at once With Undo and Redo, custom labels and marks; by key, by mouse, from menus or the command palette, with Auto Advance; custom labels in colours of their own | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #229 |
Keywords Keywording and the Keyword List panels on the selection, with completion, counts and keyword sets on ⌥1 to ⌥9, the keyword painter, keywords dragged onto photos; full paths in each photo's sidecar, synonyms and export flags, Lightroom Classic's keyword file both ways, and exports following each keyword's flags | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #235 |
The camera's settings in a panel (EXIF) In Develop's right panel and the Library's Photo panel, as Lightroom Classic's Metadata panel lists them in its EXIF view; today only a line under the histogram | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #525 |
Metadata editing and presets The Metadata panel: IPTC fields on many photos at once, presets that replace, append or prefix, code replacements, and Edit Capture Time with the camera's time zone, each with Undo, carried into exports | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #236 |
Collections and smart collections In the left panel with All Photographs, Previous Import, Marked and Rejected, the panels, Group By and the filter bar working on each as on a folder; photos dragged onto a collection; a target collection; smart collections from a rule editor that is the query's text; saved in each photo's sidecar by path, so moving photos never breaks them, and kept current, with stacks | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #237 |
Metadata shared with other apps (XMP) Other apps' XMP is read, a corrected capture time included; standard | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #238 |
Import from cards and cameras A card's photos browsed and culled from their previews before copying, those already imported left out; folder and name templates with a live example; metadata presets applied on import; a backup copy; every copy verified before a card is said to be safe to erase; the window opening when a card is inserted; an import cancelled or cut short resumed or rolled back whole; cards of JPEGs browsed from what their files hold first | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #241 |
Moving files and folders With a preview, Undo and Stop; copies with ⌥ or Copy to Folder, whose Undo moves them to the Trash; and Recently Trashed to put photos back after Undo is gone | YesClassic | In progress· Phase 4 | #240 |
Removing photos The photo you're editing, or a selection, moved to the Trash from its menu, the Photo menu or the Delete key, with Undo, and put back from Recently Trashed; Lightroom Classic can also take a photo out of its catalog and keep the file | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #370 |
Stacks Raw and JPEG pairs, bursts and focus stacks; in the grid and filmstrip, bursts open with every frame shown, pairs and stacks made by hand closed with their counts, on Lightroom Classic's keys, with Remove from Stack, Split Stack, and moving a photo up, down or by dragging it within its stack in the grid or the filmstrip, the order kept in each photo's sidecar | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #242 |
Bringing a Lightroom Classic catalog Ratings, flags, labels, keywords and collections, from a copy of the catalog, with a report, in a window that shows each stage with its rate and time left, and quicker from a spinning disk; Capture One and darktable libraries too | Yes | In progress· Phase 4 | #243#244#474#475 |
Bringing an Apple Photos library Chosen albums copied into your folders with a report first and Undo Import, favourites as picks, dates and original names, each album a collection and Photos' edits stacked over their originals, and new photos in followed albums offered or imported on their own; Photos is only read, and ratings, captions and keywords wait for a build with the macOS 27 SDK | Partlymobile | In progress· Phase 4 | #488#489 |
Apple Photos albums used where they are The albums you choose shown in the library without copying, their originals downloaded from iCloud when a photo is viewed at full size, edited or exported; edits kept by Redlamp on your Mac | No | In progress· Phase 4 | #495#496#497#498#499#500#504#505#506 |
Library Health Exact duplicates, damaged and misnamed files, and a rule for raw and JPEG pairs, each shown only while it has findings and moved to the Trash only from a list you confirm, with Undo; proposals drawn in the grid; Keep Anyway; photos whose files went missing, found again with Locate… (the others beside the file offered too) or removed from the library | Partly | In progress· Phase 4 | #264#279 |
Photos grouped into moments In the grid, by pauses in shooting with one Tighter–Looser control, or by day, folder, camera, lens or orientation; each group with its count and picks, opened and closed, ⌥← and ⌥→ between them, and the moments that have no pick shown alone, and found by the filter bar and smart collections | No | In progress· Phase 4 | #280 |
Soft frames found in bursts The sharpest frame of each burst at the camera's focus point, proposed and never applied to a frame you decided. Lightroom Classic's assisted culling judges sharpness; whether it ranks a burst isn't documented | Partly | In progress· Phase 4 | #281 |
People (face recognition) and Map | Yes | Later | #248#249 |
AI search On the Mac | Yes | Later | #246#247 |
AI-assisted culling Lightroom's Assisted Culling judges sharpness, faces and eyes; rating, flagging and labelling work on whole selections in Redlamp's Library today | Yes | Later | #137 |
Similar photos | Yes | Later | #245 |
Print, book, slideshow and web
Out of scope| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Redlamp develops photos; it doesn't lay out prints Out of scope Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Out of scope | |
Book, Slideshow and Web Out of scope Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Out of scope | |
Publish services, and sharing to Adobe's web and Firefly Redlamp has no cloud service Out of scope Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | Out of scope |
Platforms and sync
2 of 8 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Mac macOS 26 on Apple Silicon, free and open source, with no subscription. Not sandboxed yet; photos decode in a sandboxed service DoneDifferent approach Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | |
Windows Redlamp is built for Apple's platforms Out of scope Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Out of scope | |
iPad and iPhone The same engine, after 1.0 | Yes | Planned· Phase 5 | #410#412#413#414#415#468 |
Edits shared between Macs Through iCloud Drive: sidecars sync safely and conflicting copies merge. A photo that's open doesn't reload yet when another Mac changes its edit DoneBehind Lightroom Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | DoneBehind Lightroom | |
A library shared between Macs Ratings, keywords and collections another Mac changes, through iCloud Drive or a shared volume, merged field by field | Yescloud | Planned· Phase 4 | #262 |
Working on your photos away from home Over your own private network, such as Tailscale, with the photos left on a drive at home rather than in a cloud; a study first | Yescloud | Planned· Phase 4 | #377 |
Edits moving between your Mac, iPad and iPhone Through iCloud Drive and Files, rather than Adobe's cloud | Yescloud | Planned· Phase 5 | #411 |
Cloud sync with smart previews Later Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | Later | |
Photos library and a Photos editing extension | Partlymobile | Planned· Phase 2 | #386 |