Compare
Redlamp and Lightroom, feature by feature
The Lightroom features photographers know, and where Redlamp stands on each. Redlamp is in pre-alpha, so much of the list is still ahead; each row says plainly what works, what's being built and what isn't coming. Features that work haven't yet been compared with Lightroom's results unless a row says so.
- Done
- 74
- In progress
- 5
- Planned
- 32
- Later
- 15
- Undecided
- 6
- Out of scope
- 6
- Done:
- works in the app today.
- In progress:
- being built.
- Planned:
- on the roadmap, in the phase shown.
- Later:
- after 1.0.
- Undecided:
- Lightroom has it; Redlamp hasn't decided yet.
- Out of scope:
- left out, with the reason.
- Not yet compared:
- works, but its results haven't been checked against Lightroom's side by side.
- Behind, Beyond or Different:
- a known gap, more than Lightroom does, or a different approach by design.
Lightroom checked against: Lightroom Classic 15.6 and the Lightroom Desktop and mobile releases of September 2026, from The Lightroom Queen's release notes (checked 4 October 2026); not yet against Adobe's own pages. Read from docs/lightroom-comparison.md at commit 95a532f, which follows the project's tracker; each row links to its GitHub issue, where the work can be followed and discussed.
138 features
Files and cameras
4 of 10 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Raw files from most cameras Through LibRaw 0.22; 25 cameras are verified by the decode tests, Hasselblad and Phase One medium format among them (every camera). Nikon's High Efficiency NEFs and the Sony A7 V don't open yet, and raws other than DNG use one colour matrix per camera, where DNGs blend two by white balance | Yes | DoneBehind Lightroom | #14#18#168#169 |
Fujifilm X-Trans raw files A first-generation demosaic; a Markesteijn-class one is planned. Fujifilm exposure differs from the camera's by up to ±0.9 EV, depending on the body | Yes | DoneBehind Lightroom | #20 |
Apple ProRAW and other phone DNGs Gain maps and embedded camera profiles are applied, and ProRAW can render with the iPhone's own look | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #16#17#29 |
JPEG XL DNGs Linear ones (iPhone ProRAW) open; JPEG XL mosaic DNGs don't yet | Yes | In progress· Phase 2 | #23 |
Testing your own camera The camera bench checks your raws against the camera's own JPEG on your Mac, and sends only the measurements, which add to the cameras page | No | In progress· Phase 2 | #174#175#176#177 |
JPEG, HEIC, TIFF and PNG Shown as the file at default settings, as Lightroom does | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #42 |
PSD, AVIF and JPEG XL files Planned· Phase 2 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | |
WebP files Undecided Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Undecided | |
Per-camera raw defaults By camera, lens, ISO and file type | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #68 |
Tethered capture Later Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Later | |
Video Redlamp develops still photos Out of scope Lightroom: Yesbasic trims | Yesbasic trims | Out of scope |
Light and colour
14 of 23 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
White balance: presets, Temp and Tint, eyedropper and Auto A camera white-balance model built on each camera's colour matrix DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Exposure, Contrast, Highlights, Shadows, Whites and Blacks Highlights and Shadows keep the texture inside each region for new edits | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #9#25 |
Auto settings A heuristic Auto, as a starting point DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Texture, Clarity and Dehaze Clarity and Dehaze follow the photo's edges for new edits, so a skyline gets no bright and dark bands | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #26#157 |
Vibrance and Saturation Boosts stop at the edge of the output's colours instead of clipping | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #27 |
Tone curve: parametric and point curves With split points and the point curve's presets DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Tone curve: separate red, green and blue curves Planned· Phase 2 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | |
Targeted Adjustment Tool Drag on the photo to move a curve or a colour band Planned· Phase 2 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | |
Color Mixer: hue, saturation and luminance per colour Works in OKLCh DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Black and white DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
B&W mix: brightness per colour band Today the Color Mixer's Luminance shapes a black-and-white photo Planned· Phase 2 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | |
Point Color Lightroom's now has a Variance slider too, which evens out similar colours; Capture One's separate hue, saturation and lightness uniformity, for skin, is proposed | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #181 |
Color Grading Shadows, midtones, highlights and global wheels, with Blending and Balance DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Profiles Profiles are Base Looks inside Recipes: six built-in looks and the film looks, each with an Amount slider (0–200) | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #66 |
Camera-matching looks Four looks measured from Fujifilm cameras' own JPEGs (one provisional), under Redlamp's own names | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #34 |
More camera-matching looks (Eterna, Classic Negative, Acros and others) Need more photos with the camera's JPEG beside the raw | Yes | In progress· Phase 3 | #34#40 |
DNG camera profiles Dual-illuminant colour and the embedded HueSatMap; a profile's look is offered as a Base Look | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #17#29 |
Custom `.dcp` camera profiles Deferred on 2 October 2026 Later Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Later | |
ICC input profiles | No | Planned· Phase 2 | #30 |
Calibration panel Shadows Tint and the red, green and blue primaries DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Process versions An edit keeps rendering the way it was made; moving it to a newer process is your choice | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #2 |
HDR editing and export Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | |
Adaptive (AI) profile and personalised auto settings | Yes | Later | #134#135 |
Detail
2 of 5 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Sharpening Lightroom's four controls; the photo's noise and grain aren't sharpened | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #127 |
Noise reduction Lightroom's six controls, scaled to each photo's measured noise; calibrated profiles for the first ten bodies wait on calibration shots | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #102#103 |
AI Denoise On the Mac, working on the raw data, without writing a new file | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #107#108#109 |
Super Resolution 2x and 4x, faithful to the photo rather than inventing detail | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #124#125 |
Raw Details Later Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Later |
Lens and geometry
7 of 10 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Lens corrections the raw file carries DNG opcodes, Sony's and Fujifilm's built-in corrections | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #79#80 |
Lens corrections from Panasonic and OM System raws | Yes | In progress· Phase 3 | #80 |
Adobe LCP lens profiles Profiles you put in Redlamp's Lens Profiles folder; Redlamp doesn't ship Adobe's | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #82#159 |
A built-in lens profile database The lensfun database, once a licence question is answered | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #81 |
Manual distortion and vignetting DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Remove Chromatic Aberration and Defringe From the lens profile, or measured from the photo's own edges | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #87 |
Upright: Auto, Level, Vertical, Full and Guided Corrects only where the photo's straight edges agree | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #85#86 |
Transform sliders | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #83 |
Crop and straighten Aspect presets, Lightroom's overlays, the Straighten tool and Constrain to Image | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #84 |
Lens Blur | Yes | Later | #138 |
Effects
4 of 4 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Post-crop vignette With Highlights, to keep bright areas bright DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Grain Sized to the frame and strongest in the shadows, as film's is | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #39 |
Halation and bloom The glow film gives bright lights | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #37#38 |
Light leaks, dust and scratches, and frames | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #45 |
Masking
14 of 16 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Linear and radial gradients DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Brush, with Auto Mask and pen pressure | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #61 |
Color and luminance range | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #51 |
Subject, Sky and Background Computed on the Mac; photos are never uploaded. Sky also uses Depth Anything 3, an open model trained partly on data Redlamp couldn't use itself. Edges are solved when a mask is made, not refined again as you edit | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #53#62 |
People and their parts Face parts from Apple Vision; body skin, clothes and hair from SAM 3, a download under Meta's SAM License | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #53#58 |
Objects Hover to preview, click to select (Segment Anything 2.1, an 80 MB download, an open model trained partly on data Redlamp couldn't use itself) | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #55 |
Landscape Water, vegetation, mountains, architecture and ground, from SAM 3 (a 988 MB download under Meta's SAM License); Lightroom's also finds snow | Yes | DoneBehind Lightroom | #62 |
Depth Range From the photo's own depth map, or estimated by Depth Anything, an open model trained partly on data Redlamp couldn't use itself | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #59 |
Refine AI mask edges Refine Edges, and a Refine Edge brush that solves an edge again where you paint; Lightroom has Feather and Edge sliders | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #1 |
Mask presets (Blue Sky, Whiten Teeth and others) Save your own from any mask DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Add, Subtract, Intersect, invert and duplicate DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Local adjustments in masks Local Whites and Blacks are approximated with tonal-region gains | Yes | DoneBehind Lightroom | #49 |
Curves inside masks Planned· Phase 3 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | |
Point Color inside masks An Even Skin Tone preset on Face Skin and Body Skin is proposed | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #181 |
Update AI masks across photos Pasted and synced settings recompute their AI masks for each photo | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #149 |
Reuse a mask inside another, and keep only its textured areas Lightroom can start a new mask from an existing one; Redlamp also adds, subtracts or intersects one inside another, and a mask's Detail keeps only its textured or flat areas | Partly | DoneBeyond Lightroom | #50#52 |
Healing and removal
5 of 8 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Heal and Clone Spots and brushed strokes, each finding its own source | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #118 |
Content-aware Remove A classical fill on the Mac; large areas wait for generative fill | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #153 |
Remove people and objects with a click | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #154 |
Find and remove things named in words Trash, signs, cables and more, found anywhere in the photo; something as large as a car leaves a smeared patch until generative fill arrives | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #154 |
Generative Remove An opt-in download that runs on the Mac, labelled as generated fill | Yescloud, credits | Planned· Phase 3 | #156 |
Dust removal and Visualize Spots Also across a shoot: specks in the same place on the sensor are healed in every photo | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #119 |
Reflection removal Later Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Later | |
Red Eye and Pet Eye | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #136 |
Generative and cloud AI
0 of 4 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Generative Expand: fill beyond the frame Undecided Lightroom: YesDesktop and mobile, not Classic | YesDesktop and mobile, not Classic | Undecided | |
Generative Upscale (Topaz) Redlamp's planned Super Resolution is faithful rather than generative | YesDesktop; cloud, credits | Undecided | DEC-14 |
AI sharpening for blur and missed focus (Topaz) Proposed for Redlamp as a head on its own raw denoiser, on the Mac | YesDesktop; cloud, credits | Undecided | #129 |
Edit by describing the result (Prompt to Edit, Firefly) Undecided Lightroom: YesDesktop early access; cloud, credits | YesDesktop early access; cloud, credits | Undecided |
Presets and looks
5 of 6 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Presets Presets, profiles and LUTs are all Recipes, with an Amount slider; Lightroom's words still work in search | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | #69 |
Lightroom presets (`.xmp`) Imported with a report of what came across exactly, approximately or not at all. Sliders aren't yet calibrated against Lightroom's renders, so a preset can look different | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #73 |
LUTs (`.cube`, `.3dl`, HaldCLUT) Imported directly, including LUTs made for camera log footage; Lightroom takes LUTs only wrapped as profiles | Partly | DoneBeyond Lightroom | #31#158 |
Film stock simulations (Portra, Tri-X and others) 36 looks from 30 stocks, built from the manufacturers' datasheets; Lightroom's film-inspired presets don't replicate particular films | Partlyfilm-inspired presets | DoneBeyond Lightroom | #41#46 |
Film looks fitted from film shot beside digital With charts and lab scans, per stock | No | Planned· Phase 3 | #43 |
Camera recipe cards Fujifilm-style recipes, typed in as the card lists them DoneOnly in Redlamp Lightroom: No | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | |
Premium and recommended presets Redlamp has no cloud service Out of scope Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | Out of scope |
Working on many photos
4 of 7 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Folders A working set of folders, not a catalog; nothing on disk is moved | YesClassic | DoneDifferent approach | #99 |
Copy and paste settings Lightroom's checklist, remembered | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #70 |
Sync and Auto Sync | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #149#150 |
Ratings, flags and colour labels Saved with the photo's edit, shown on the filmstrip DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Batch export | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #78 |
Batch rename Undecided Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Undecided | |
Open photos edited in Lightroom Converts Lightroom's XMP sidecars once, and never writes them | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | #74 |
History and versions
3 of 5 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
History and unlimited undo The last 20 editing sessions are kept with the photo DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Snapshots DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Virtual copies and versions | Yes | Planned· Phase 2 | #71 |
Before and after Three layouts DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Reference view Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 |
Viewing
5 of 7 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Zoom, Navigator and clipping Fit, Fill, 1:1 and 2:1; Lightroom zooms to 11:1 DoneBehind Lightroom Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneBehind Lightroom | |
Histogram you can drag to adjust DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Lightroom Classic's keyboard shortcuts 83 actions on 87 key bindings DoneNot yet compared Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | |
Command palette Every action and slider from the keyboard (⌘K) | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #98 |
Sensor clipping and a colour-assessment view | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #96 |
Soft proofing Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Planned· Phase 4 | |
Secondary display Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 |
Merging photos
1 of 5 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Focus stacking Stacks are found for you; merge, view the depth map and retouch, and the result develops like a raw | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp | #112#113#115 |
Focus stacking: lens corrections, halo handling and DNG output | No | In progress· Phase 3 | #113#114 |
AI-assisted focus stacking Fewer frames, handheld sequences, better edges | No | Planned· Phase 4 | #117 |
HDR merge | Yes | Later | #139 |
Panorama | Yes | Later | #139 |
Export
4 of 10 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
JPEG, HEIC, AVIF, PNG and TIFF 8, 10 or 16 bits, in sRGB or Display P3 | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #75#77 |
Size, metadata and export presets With Export with Previous | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #77 |
Adobe RGB, ProPhoto and custom ICC output Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | |
DNG, PSD and JPEG XL output Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | |
Watermarks Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | |
Output sharpening Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | |
Edit in Photoshop or another app Planned· Phase 4 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 4 | |
Content Credentials | Yes | Planned· Phase 3 | #120 |
The edit embedded in exported files | Yes | DoneNot yet compared | #76 |
Command-line rendering and export The DoneOnly in Redlamp Lightroom: No | No | DoneOnly in Redlamp |
Library and organising
0 of 6 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Catalog, collections and smart collections Redlamp is an editor; a library is a separate, later track Later Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Later | |
Keywords and metadata editing Later Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Later | |
People (face recognition) and Map Later Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Later | |
AI search Later Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Later | |
Culling in a grid, and AI-assisted culling Lightroom's Assisted Culling judges sharpness, faces and eyes; rating, flagging and labelling work in Redlamp's filmstrip today | Yes | Later | #137 |
Stacking similar photos, and finding duplicates Later Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Later |
Print, book, slideshow and web
Out of scope| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Redlamp develops photos; it doesn't lay out prints Out of scope Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Out of scope | |
Book, Slideshow and Web Out of scope Lightroom: YesClassic | YesClassic | Out of scope | |
Publish services, and sharing to Adobe's web and Firefly Redlamp has no cloud service Out of scope Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | Out of scope |
Platforms and sync
2 of 6 done| Feature | Lightroom | Redlamp | On GitHub |
|---|---|---|---|
Mac macOS 26 on Apple Silicon, free and open source, with no subscription. Not sandboxed yet; photos decode in a sandboxed service DoneDifferent approach Lightroom: Yes | Yes | DoneDifferent approach | |
Windows Redlamp is built for Apple's platforms Out of scope Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Out of scope | |
iPad and iPhone The same engine, after 1.0 Planned· Phase 5 Lightroom: Yes | Yes | Planned· Phase 5 | |
Edits shared between Macs Through iCloud Drive: sidecars sync safely and conflicting copies merge. A photo that's open doesn't reload yet when another Mac changes its edit DoneBehind Lightroom Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | DoneBehind Lightroom | |
Edits moving between your Mac, iPad and iPhone Through iCloud Drive and Files, rather than Adobe's cloud Planned· Phase 5 Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | Planned· Phase 5 | |
Cloud sync with smart previews Later Lightroom: Yescloud | Yescloud | Later | |
Photos library and a Photos editing extension Planned· Phase 2 Lightroom: Partlymobile | Partlymobile | Planned· Phase 2 |